Sunday, August 26, 2007

Movie Roundup: Scary Cats Edition

Catching up with the recently viewed while enjoying my brand-new Val Lewton boxset. I watched the commentaries on Cat People (#4, 1942), I Walked With A Zombie (#3, 1943), The Leopard Man (#10, 1943) and the first half of The 7th Victim (#8, 1943) this afternoon. Now I've got Cat People playing with its actual soundtrack.

At least that's what I was doing three weeks ago when I started this. Might as well post it now.


The Thing From Another World - This template-setting sci-fi/horror film from 1941 has been hugely influential and it's not hard to see why. The plot is essentially the same as any number of later films, most notably Ridley Scott's Alien (#4, 1979). A group of scientists on a remote arctic outposts discover a crashed flying saucer and bring it back to their base. Soon their on the run from a near invincible and quite murderous alien. Produced by Howard Hawks, and perhaps to some extent directed by him as well (it's credited to Christian Nyby, Hawks's editor on a number of classics who went on to direct a lot of television). The Hawks influence on the film is unmistakable. Professional men doing a difficult job in an extreme environment (The Dawn Patrol, Only Angels Have Wings, Red River, Rio Bravo, etc) combined with snappy, overlapping dialogue (Bringing Up Baby, His Girl Friday, The Big Sleep, Ball Of Fire). This distinguishes it from Scott's virtual remake: Alien is a slasher horror film, Hawks and Nyby's film is a screwball adventure. The #2 film of 1951.

Jour de fête - The Northwest Film Forum's been running a five-week, five film 100th anniversary series of Jacques Tatí films that's required me to rearrange my work so I can see these essential films. This is the first, his first feature as a director, about a French village on the day the fair comes to town. Tatí plays the bicycle-riding mailman who sees a short film about, he is told, the American post office (it's actually a series of remarkable motorcycle stunts. Tatí tries to match the American speed and efficiency and hilarity ensues. Tatí's style is already in place, at least visually (fairly long takes chronicling the slow buildups op the sight gags) and in terms of dialogue (there isn't much), but the film doesn't play with sound as much as his later Hulot films do (especially Playtime). The #5 film of 1949.

Zhou Yu's Train - Gong Li and The Other Tony Leung star in Sun Zhou's atmospheric, but perhaps needlessly complex romance about a ceramicist and a poet. Li takes the train every weekend to visit TOTL. One trip she meets a vet and starts taking another train to hook up with him. This rather conventional love triangle story is complicated by a jumbled narrative timeline and the fact that Li apparently plays an entirely different character from some point in the future, a fact which we never really figure out until the end of the movie. I'm not sure if I'm happy or annoyed at this complexity. A Rubik's romance isn't necessarily a bad thing, but sometimes I'd rather films be more narratively simple. Maybe I've just been watching too much Ozu (is such a thing possible?) The #8 film of 2002.

Born Yesterday - Corrupt capitalist hires four-eyed journalist to tutor his ditzy blonde girlfriend so she'll be less embarrassing in high society. Blonde learns a thing or two and realizes her tycoon is a crook and outs him, while running off with the geeky writer, who turns out to be William Holden. An iconic performance from Judy Holliday is the highlight, and director George Cukor never quite allows the film to descend into the filmed-theatre genre it so desperately wants to join. A fine film, #12 of 1950.

Knocked Up - Writer-director Judd Apatow's follow-up to The 40-Year Old Virgin (#10, 2005) has fat slacker Seth Rogan impregnate hot E! reporter Katherine Heigl. Inspiring a lefty hack critic backlash, she decides to keep the baby and try to have a relationship with the loser. Another kind of hack critic, David Denby, complains that Heigl isn't as funny as Rogan, which misses the point entirely. Denby presents an old school feminist critique of the recent wave on romantic comedies, of which Apatow's are two of the most successful, commercially and critically. They don't measure up to the screwball comedies of the 30s and 40s because the women aren't as interesting, or as funny, as the men. But these films, and Apatow's in particular, are post-feminist. They're an example of Gen X's reassertion of traditional family values in a post-revolutionary world. The 40 Year-Old Virgin is a celebration of abstinence and monogamy and a rejection of sex without love (a favorite activity of the preceding generation). Similarly, Knocked Up examines all the arguments against the nuclear family and rejects them, reformulating the family on a gender-equal setting. Why this should be seen as more reactionary than the Screwball genre, with its women as either flighty agents of chaos (Bringing Up Baby, My Man Godfrey) or professionals to be put in their place (the Tracy-Hepburn films) is beyond me.

Grand Prix - John Frankenheimer's Cinerama racing film is a fine example of overblown all-star 60s melodrama, the kind than bankrupted the studio system. James Garner, Yves Montand, Eva Marie Saint and Toshiro Mifune (dubbed) star, along with Jessica Walter, the mom from Arrested Development (she's young here, and hot too.) Some of the Formula 1 racing scenes are kind of exciting, the film film goes on forever and is rather dull. The #19 film of 1966.

A Bucket Of Blood - Roger Corman horror film that's a whole lot of fun. A wanna-be beatnik artist accidentally kills a cat and covers it with plaster. When he takes this "sculpture" into to his bohemian café, he's hailed as a great artist. Soon, he accidentally kills a cop and pulls the same trick. And then follows the psychotic killing spree in the name of ultra-realist art. One of the better Cormans, quite creepy at times, despite the absurdity of it all. The #14 film of 1959.

The Terror - Another Corman, this one starring a very young Jack Nicholson as a Napoleonic soldier who gets sidetracked by a ghost girl and embroiled in a decades old murder with a crazy old man (Boris Karloff) and a crazy old woman seeking revenge. The list of uncredited directors on imdb is pretty impressive: Francis Ford Coppola, Nicholson, Monte Hellman and Jack Hill. The #13 film of 1963.

Plunder Of The Sun - John Farrow directed film that's about equal parts The Maltese Falcon, Raiders Of The Lost Ark and Treasure Of the Sierra Madre. Glenn Ford, while vacationing in Mexico, gets caught up in a murderous quest for Aztec gold, or some such thing. An adventure noir, I guess you could say, though I don't know of many other possibilities for that subgenre. The #21 film of 1953.

Le Million - Wonderful little proto-screwball musical comedy by French director René Clair. A deadbeat artist wins the lottery, but the ticket's in his jacket, which his estranged girlfriend just happened to give away to a passing criminal. So the hunt is on throughout Paris to find the coat, the ticket, and fix his relationship. Some wonderful sequences, including an opening track of the city's rooftops and the two lovers silently reconciling while hiding behind some scenery on an opera stage. Totally charming, the #4 film of 1931.

The Simpsons Movie -

Spider-pig, Spider-pig
Does whatever a Spider-pig does
Can he walk, On a web?
No he can't 'cause he's a pig.

Ivanhoe - Being from 1952, it's a little early for the series of expensive Hollywood epics that epitomized the decadence of the late studio period. But this Sir Walter Scott adaptation is certainly as mediocre as any of those later films. Robert taylor plays the eponymous knight, Elizabeth Taylor and Joan Fontaine play the women who love him, and George Sanders, of all people, plays the Norman knight who more or less opposes him. Directed by Richard Thorpe, who in a 45-year career managed to direct nothing else I've ever heard of.

The Spanish Earth - Propaganda documentary from 1937 valorizing the struggle against fascism in the Spanish Civil War. Written by Ernest Hemingway, John Dos Passos, Lillian Hellman, and Archibald Macleish, which is impressive, and narrated by Hemingway himself (he decided to do it himself rather than use the narration Orson Welles had recorded). As a film its rather heartbreaking, in the manner of all films documenting a struggle you know will be lost. The #13 film of 1937.


Wake Island - Another John Farrow film, this one a fine, if generic WW2 film about a small island outpost holding out against overwhelming odds against the Japanese in the early days of the war. Some great action and good solid genre acting from a solid genre cast of people like Brian Donlevy, Macdonald Carey, William Bendix, and Robert Preston. The #8 film of 1942.

The Bournes Supremacy and Ultimatum - Matt Damon stars in these Paul Greengrss-directed action films, effectively underplaying his role as a amnesiac cypher that happens to be a CIA trained killing machine. In the Supremacy, the first sequel to Doug Liman's The Bourne Identity (#20, 2002), Damon quests to avenge the death of his girlfriend while uncovering some type of treason involving Brian Cox and some Russians. The MacGuffin doesn't make a whole lot of sense, and neither does the action: all swish pans and quick cuts. The Ultimatum is a little better, the action is easier to follow and the plot is a bit more essential to the Bourne character (involving the origin of his skills and CIA corruption not unrelated to the present administration). The first film is superior to either sequel. The Supremacy has almost no interest in character: aside from a very moving coda it's essentially one long action sequence. The Ultimatum doesn't have any single scene that good, but there is more exploration of Bourne's, ahem, identity. The Supremacy is the #21 film of 2004.

The Trouble With Angels - Hayley Mills is a bad influence as a teenage delinquent (she smokes cigarettes!) in this mediocre high school film. Frankly, I expect better from a fine director like Ida Lupino. The #21 film of 1966.

Mon Oncle - The third in the Northwest Film Forum's series of Jacques Tatí films, and the second I hadn't seen before. Also the second film in which he plays agent of chaos M. Hulot. A terrifically warm and funny film, as Hulot ceaselessly annoys his sister and her ultra-modernist husband and friends. If Jour de fête and M. Hulot's Holiday are about the charms of the countryside, and Playtime is about the charms of the big city, then Mon Oncle is about the intersection of country and city, old world and new. It may be the most purely funny of any of Tatí's films. The #3 film of 1958.

Cat Ballou - Revisionist/comic Western in which Jane Fonda gathers some men to help her protect her father's farm against, among them a drunken old gunfighter played by Lee Marvin, in a fine performance for which he won an Oscar. Another one of those 60s comedies which are just too weird to be funny. Though Fonda and Marvin are always fun, Nat King Cole and Stubby Kaye as singing minstrel narrators are too bizarre for me. The #17 film of 1965.

Becket - The story of the friendship of St. Thomas á Becket and King Henry II, complicated by Becket's conflicting loyalties and overdeveloped sense of honor (a whole church vs. state thing). The film's more a showcase for the great starring actors than interesting on its own terms. Richard Burton's very good as Becket, but Peter O'Toole's Henry is a lot more interesting when he played him again a few years later in The Lion In Winter (#1, 1968). John Gielgud also stars as the King of France. The #15 film of 1964.

Zodiac - Another tonal shift for director David Fincher, away from the ultra-noir darkness of Seven and Alien 3 and the over the top post-modernity of Fight Club, this mellow procedural about the famous Zodiac serial killer is all warm earthy colors and relatively long shots. It succeeds quite well in capturing both the look and the paranoid feel of the 1970s, with a few Hitchcockian attempts at suspense that don't really work if you know how the story ends. These are missteps, I think, as suspense should work especially well when you know the ending. Fincher's strengths lie elsewhere: in mood creation and shock. The cast, including Jake Gyllenhall, Robert Downey Jr and Mark Ruffalo, however, is very good.

La Notte - The second of Michelangelo Antonioni's early 60s alienation trilogy is the weakest of the three, though it paradoxically has the strongest cast. Marcello Mastrionni and Jeanne Moreau play a married couple who don't much like each other anymore, which they come to realize over a very long day which sees the death of a friend and a lavish rich people party. The film picks up at the party, when Mastrionni begins a flirtation with Monica Vitti, better looking and acting here than in the other two Antonionis. The stark and rather depressing film becomes sublime in the second to last sequence, when the three leads confront each other in Vitti's room and Antonionni's choreography of the actors movements in space is precise, moving and dramatically beautiful. This penultimate scene makes the whole film worthwhile. The #8 film of 1961.

A Walk In The Sun - Very fine WW2 film from director Lewis Milestone (All Quiet On The Western Front, Oceans 11). A group of American soldiers arrives in Italy and slowly advances to a strategic farmhouse. All the key elements of a WW2 film are there, most importantly the collective hero made up of a group of distinctive characters that are more than stereotypes or thematic signifiers (unlike in, say, Saving Private Ryan). The cast includes Dana Andrews, Richard Conte, Lloyd Bridges, John Ireland and Sterling Holloway. The screenplay's by Robert Rossen, who went on to direct All The King's Men and The Hustler. The #10 film of 1945.

Hot Blood - Director Nicholas Ray's slumming in this gypsy musical comedy starring Jane Russell and Cornel Wilde (the great tagline: "Jane Russell shakes her tamborines and drives Cornel Wild"!). Wilde gets tricked into marrying Russell, when he'd rather be a free spirit (I'm unclear on whether or not he prefers the company of men, so to speak). But, eventually he comes around and all live gypsyly ever after. The #14 film of 1956.

While The City Sleeps - Fritz Lang pseudo-noir starring Dana Andrews as a journalist on the trail of a serial killer. The solution to the crime is set up by Vincent Price as a contest for control of his newspaper between the old school Thomas Mitchell (Andrews's friend) and George Sanders and his newfangled newswire. Dark and cynical, it's a fascinating exploration of the codependency of the media and crime from within the confines of a studio genre film. It works on both levels. The #11 film of 1956.


L'Eclisse - The best Michelangelo Antonioni movie I've seen thus far. In style it picks right up from that great next to last scene of La Notte and keeps it going for the rest of the film. Monica Vitti leaves her husband and their cozy book and painting film home to wander the modernist city. She meets a hyperactive stockbroker played by Alain Delon and fitfully begins a romance. There are a few fascinating long sequences in the Rome stock exchange, with the chaos on the trading floor being strangely comprehensible as the market collapses. Old World architecture and attitudes are constantly being replaced by modernity, and Vitti is stuck in between, with seemingly no idea where to go or what she wants. The final sequence is as hauntingly beautiful as it is inexplicable. The #4 film of 1962.

The Shootist - John Wayne's last film is a revisionist Western in the 70s style. Wayne plays a dying gunfighter who doesn't especially want to fight anymore but gets dragged into one last shootout with some local jerks. Set around the turn of the century, director Don Siegel pounds home the idea that Wayne's outlived his time. The excellent supporting cast includes Lauren Bacall, Jimmy Stewart, Henry Morgan and Ron Howard, who narrates the opening of the film, creating the eerie feeling that you're watching an episode of Arrested Development. The #7 film of 1976.

Stardust - Amiable fantasy/romance from director Matthew Vaughn and based on a book by Neil Gaiman. Claire Danes stars as a star who falls to Earth and gets captured by a young man who intends to bring her back to Sienna Miller so she'll marry him. Unfortunately, they get caught up in a power struggle of a family of princes who have to kill each other and find a jewel to become King while a murderous witch played by Michelle Pheiffer wants to capture Danes and eat her heart (to hold off old age). Fortunately, they meet up with a gay pirate played by Robert DeNiro who helps them out and teaches the kid some sword-fighting skills. And Ricky Gervais amd Peter O'Toole are in there somewhere, too. It doesn't have the subversive brilliance of The Princess Bride, but that's a high standard to hold anything to.

Closely Watched Trains - Classic of the Czech New Wave, it clearly owes a lot to François Truffaut. During World War 2, a young man begins training as a train dispatcher. He's got a cute girlfriend, but is having trouble consummating their relationship (she's all for it). So, he tries and fails to kill himself and is advised by his doctor to seek the company of an older, experienced woman. He finds one in the resistance and in that and the act of blowing up a train he finally "becomes a man". A rather silly, depressing film enlivened by some genuinely funny moments, good acting all around and some very nice black and white cinematography. The #9 film of 1966.

Air Force - Pretty much the perfect World War 2 film. Director Howard Hawks's style is perfect for the collective hero of that genre, where everyone talks at once but still manage to become distinct and interesting characters. The film follows the crew of a B-17 bomber as it leaves San Francisco for Hawaii on December 6, 1941 and arrives at Pearl Harbor just after the attack. They then have to leave immediately for Wake Island, where the Marines are under siege and from there they go straight to The Philippines. Along the way they get a tour of the early stages of the war, get shot at, and mold into a real crew, with each member playing their role in the plane's survival. There's plenty of comedy, but real pathos to, especially with Harry Carey as the grizzled crew chief with a son stationed in Manilla. John Garfield is also fine as a gunner who initially wants to quit but changes his mind after Pearl Harbor. The action scenes are outstanding, with what looks like a blend of original, stock and documentary footage. One dogfight in particular is a clear influence on Star Wars and is very good, though without Lucas's hyperkinetic editing. The #3 film of 1943.

Monday, August 20, 2007

The Best Non-English Language Films Of All-Time


A blogger named Edward Copeland is polling the internet film community to find out the consensus best non-English language films ever made.  He polled 51 people (a fairly prestigious group: Jonathan Rosenbaum, David Ansen, Jim Emerson, Amy Taubin among others) to come up with a list of 121 nominees (every film that received at least 3 votes).  Any one can vote and we have until Sept. 16 to submit a ranked ballot of 25 films.



These are the nominees:

Aguirre, the Wrath of God directed by Werner Herzog
Ali: Fear Eats the Soul directed by Rainer Werner Fassbinder
All About My Mother directed by Pedro Almodovar
Amarcord directed by Federico Fellini
Amelie directed by Jean-Pierre Jeunet
Amores Perros directed by Alejandro González Iñárritu
Andrei Rublev directed by Andrei Tarkovsky
Army of Shadows directed by Jean-Pierre Melville
Ashes and Diamonds directed by Andrzej Wajda
Au Hasard Balthazar directed by Robert Bresson
Band of Outsiders directed by Jean-Luc Godard
The Battle of Algiers directed by Gillo Pontecorvo
Beauty and the Beast directed by Jean Cocteau
Belle de Jour directed by Luis Bunuel
The Bicycle Thief directed by Vittorio de Sica
The Bitter Tears of Petra von Kant directed by Rainer Werner Fassbinder
Black Orpheus directed by Marcel Camus
Three Colors: Blue directed by Krzysztof Kieslowski
The Blue Angel directed by Josef von Sternberg
Breathless directed by Jean-Luc Godard
Celine and Julie Go Boating directed by Jacques Rivette
Children of Paradise directed by Marcel Carne
Chungking Express directed by Wong Kar-Wai
Cinema Paradiso directed by Giuseppe Tornatore
City of God directed by Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund
Cleo From 5 to 7 directed by Agnes Varda
Come and See directed by Elem Klimov
The Conformist directed by Bernardo Bertolucci
Contempt directed by Jean-Luc Godard
The Cranes Are Flying directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili
Cries and Whispers directed by Ingmar Bergman
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon directed by Ang Lee
Das Boot directed by Wolfgang Petersen
Day for Night directed by Francois Truffaut
Day of Wrath directed by Carl Theodor Dreyer
The Decalogue directed by Krzysztof Kieslowski
Dersu Uzala directed by Akira Kurosawa
The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie directed by Luis Bunuel
The Double Life of Veronique directed by Krzysztof Kieslowski
The Earrings of Madame De... directed by Max Ophuls
8 1/2 directed by Federico Fellini
The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser directed by Werner Herzog
Exterminating Angel directed by Luis Bunuel
Eyes Without a Face directed by Georges Franju
Fanny and Alexander directed by Ingmar Bergman
Farewell My Concubine directed by Chen Kaige
Forbidden Games directed by René Clément
The 400 Blows directed by Francois Truffaut
The Gospel According to St. Matthew directed by Pier Paolo Pasolini
Grand Illusion directed by Jean Renoir
The Great Silence directed by Sergio Corbucci
High and Low directed by Akira Kurosawa
Hiroshima Mon Amour directed by Alain Resnais
Ikiru directed by Akira Kurosawa
In the Mood for Love directed by Wong Kar-Wai
Jules and Jim directed by Francois Truffaut
La Dolce Vita directed by Federico Fellini
La Strada directed by Federico Fellini
Last Year at Marienbad directed by Alain Resnais
L'Atalante directed by Jean Vigo
Late Spring directed by Yasujiro Ozu
L'Avventura directed by Michelangelo Antonioni
L'Eclisse directed by Michelangelo Antonioni
The Leopard directed by Luchino Visconti
Le Samourai directed by Jean-Pierre Melville
Lola Montes directed by Max Ophuls
M directed by Fritz Lang
The Marriage of Maria Braun directed by Rainer Werner Fassbinder
Masculin-Feminin directed by Jean-Luc Godard
My Night at Maud's directed by Eric Rohmer
Nights of Cabiria directed by Federico Fellini
Nosferatu the Vampyre directed by Werner Herzog
Open City directed by Roberto Rossellini
Ordet directed by Carl Theodor Dreyer
Orpheus directed by Jean Cocteau
Persona directed by Ingmar Bergman
Pickpocket directed by Robert Bresson
Pierrot le fou directed by Jean-Luc Godard
Playtime directed by Jacques Tati
Raise the Red Lantern directed by Zhang Yimou
Ran directed by Akira Kurosawa
Rashomon directed by Akira Kurosawa
Three Colors: Red directed by Krzysztof Kieslowski
The Red Desert directed by Michelangelo Antonioni
Rififi directed by Jules Dassin
Rocco and His Brothers directed by Luchino Visconti
The Rules of the Game directed by Jean Renoir
Run Lola Run directed by Tom Tykwer
Sansho the Bailiff directed by Kenji Mizoguchi
Satantango directed by Béla Tarr
Scenes from a Marriage directed by Ingmar Bergman
Seven Beauties directed by Lina Wertmuller
The Seven Samurai directed by Akira Kurosawa
The Seventh Seal directed by Ingmar Bergman
Shoot the Piano Player directed by Francois Truffaut
Smiles of a Summer Night directed by Ingmar Bergman
Sonatine directed by Takeski Kitano
Spirited Away directed by Hayao Miyazaki
Stolen Kisses directed by Francois Truffaut
Story of the Late Chrysanthemums directed by Kenji Mizoguchi
Suspiria directed by Dario Argento
Talk to Her directed by Pedro Almodovar
Tampopo directed by Juzo Itami
Throne of Blood directed by Akira Kurosawa
The Tin Drum directed by Volker Schlöndorff
Tokyo Story directed by Yasujiro Ozu
To Live directed by Zhang Yimou
Ugetsu monogatari directed by Kenji Mizoguchi
Umberto D directed by Vittorio de Sica
The Umbrellas of Cherbourg directed by Jacques Demy
The Vanishing directed by George Sluizer
Viridiana directed by Luis Bunuel
The Wages of Fear directed by Henri-Georges Clouzot
Three Colors: White directed by Krzysztof Kieslowski
Wild Strawberries directed by Ingmar Bergman
Wings of Desire directed by Wim Wenders
The Woman In the Dunes directed by Hiroshi Teshigahara
Yi Yi: A One and a Two directed by Edward Yang
Yojimbo directed by Akira Kurosawa
Y Tu Mama Tambien directed by Alfonso Cuaron
Z directed by Costa-Gavras


All but three of my nominees made the cut.  Guess there weren't two other people who love Millennium Mambo, A Woman Is A Woman and Taste Of Cherry as much as I do.



My nominees were:

Seven Samurai
Chungking Express
The Rules Of The Game
Millennium Mambo
Pierrot le fou
Playtime
Au hasard Balthazar
8 1/2
Ugetsu
The Seventh Seal
Ran
A Woman Is A Woman
The Umbrellas Of Cherbourg
Three Colors: Blue
Hiroshima mon amour
Late Spring
Andrei Rublev
Celine And Julie Go Boating
Last Year At Marienbad
The Double Life Of Veronique
Satantango
Nights Of Cabiria
Day Of Wrath
Sansho The Bailiff
Taste Of Cherry

And those are in ranked order, because I do that. Since I submitted the ballot, I've seen L'Eclisse and would certainly have voted for it ahead of, at least, Taste Of Cherry.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

Movies Of The Year: The Big List

I've decided to go ahead and post the rest of the Movies Of the Year lists, if only for organizational reasons. It'll be easier to keep track of things if I can slot them into the list as I watch them, instead of waiting until I get around to writing that particular year. I'm still going to keep up with the year by year countdowns, so this is just the rankings. All the lists, from 1915 through 2006 can always be found on the sidebar.

Here's how it works: A film's year is determined by what year IMDB says it is. Not because IMDB is especially accurate, but just because I need some easy to use way to figure out what movies I've seen and when they're from, and IMDB's the easiest and most comprehensive resource there is. So, I browse IMDB by year, pick out all the movies I've seen (and the ones I think I should see) and put them in some kind of order.

The order isn't definitive: ranking works of art is not meant to be a hierarchical activity, but rather an organizational one. It gives me a chance to write about some movies. It's interesting trivially and comparatively to see what movies came out at the same time, to see the progression of film history. And lists are just plain fun to argue over. They are meant to be conversation starters, not finishers. I don't have any particular criteria for what ranks above what, it's just my own subjective opinion, informed by a reasonable knowledge of film and film history (though not nearly what it should be, as you can see from the Unseen lists in the individual Movies Of The Year entries).

The rankings change over time: when I see a new movie from a year I've already posted, I add it to The Big List here. Sometimes I'll see a movie again and my opinion of it will change, or my feelings about a film will evolve over time, and so I'll move it up or down its list here as well. The Big List is, and always will be, a work in progress.


1915:

1. The Cheat
2. A Fool There Was
3. The Birth Of A Nation

1916:

1917:

1. The Immigrant
2. The Cure

1918:

1. A Dog's Life

1919:

1. Broken Blossoms
2. When The Clouds Roll By

1920:

1. One Week
2. Dr. Jeckyll And Mr. Hyde
3. The Cabinet Of Dr. Caligari

1921:

1. The Kid
2. The Play House
3. The 'High Sign'
4. The Sheik

1922:

1. Nosferatu: A Symphony Of Horror
2. Nanook Of The North
3. Cops
4. Dr. Mabuse: The Gambler
5. The Blacksmith

1923:

1. Our Hospitality
2. The Three Ages
3. The Balloonatic

1924:

1. Sherlock, Jr.
2. Greed

1925:

1. Battleship Potemkin
2. Seven Chances
3. The Gold Ryuh
4. The Phantom Of The Opera

1926:

1. Faust

1927:

1. Sunrise: A Song Of Two Humans
2. The General
3. Metropolis
4. It

1928:

1. The Passion Of Joan Of Arc
2. Steamboat Bill, Jr.
3. The Circus
4. Speedy

1929:

1. The Man With A Movie Camera
2. Blackmail
3. Pandora's Box
4. The Coconuts

1930:

1. The Dawn Patrol
2. Animal Crackers
3. All Quiet On The Western Front
4. Abraham Lincoln

1931:

1. City Lights
2. M
3. Monkey Business
4. Frankenstein
5. The Public Enemy
6. Night Nurse
7. Little Caesar
8. The Criminal Code
9. Arrowsmith

1932:

1. Scarface
2. Trouble In Paradise
3. Boudu Saved From Drowning
4. Vampyr
5. Horse Feathers
6. Blonde Venus
7. The Old Dark House
8. Bill Of Divorcement
9. Rain
10. Grand Hotel
11. Freaks

1933:

1. Duck Soup
2. King Kong
3. 42nd Street
4. Baby Face
5. Golddiggers Of 1933
6. Queen Christina
7. Little Women
8. She Done Him Wrong

1934:

1. L'Atalante
2. The Thin Man
3. Judge Priest
4. The Man Who Knew Too Much
5. Twentieth Century
6. It Happened One Night
7. A Lost Lady
8. The Lost Patrol
9. The Gay Divorcee
10. Death Takes A Holiday

1935:

1. Top Hat
2. The 39 Steps
3. The Devil Is A Woman
4. The Informer
5. Sylvia Scarlett
6. Mutiny On The Bounty
7. A Night At The Opera
8. Captain Blood
9. Mark Of The Vampire

1936:

1. Modern Times
2. Swing Time
3. Sisters Of Gion
4. Fury
5. Follow The Fleet
6. Last Of The Mohicans
7. My Man Godfrey
8. After The Thin Man
9. Mary Of Scotland
10. The Garden Of Allah
11. The Petrified Forest

1937:

1. The Awful Truth
2. The Grand Illusion
3. Snow White And The Seven Dwarves
4. The Hurricane
5. A Star Is Born
6. Shall We Dance
7. Pepe le Moko
8. A Day At The Races
9. Nothing Sacred
10. Stage Door
11. Lost Horizon
12. Stella Dallas

1938:

1. Bringing Up Baby
2. The Adventures Of Robin Hood
3. Alexander Nevsky
4. The Lady Vanishes
5. You Can't Take It With You
6. Angels With Dirty faces
7. Holiday

1939:

1. The Rules Of The Game
2. Young Mr. Lincoln
3. Mr. Smith Goes To Washington
4. Stagecoach
5. Ninotchka
6. The Story Of The Late Chrysanthemums
7. Only Angels Have Wings
8. Love Affair
9. Destry Rides Again
10. Gunga Din
11. The Wizard Of Oz
12. Goodbye Mr. Chips
13. The Women
14. Jamaica Inn
15. The Roaring Twenties
16. The Four Feathers
17. Gone With The Wind
18. Wuthering Heights
19. Man In The Iron Mask

1940:

1. Fantasia
2. Rebecca
3. The Shop Around The Corner
4. The Philadelphia Story
5. His Girl Friday
6. The Bank Dick
7. Pinocchio
8. The Thief Of Baghdad
9. The Long Voyage Home
10. The Grapes Of Wrath
11. The Great Dictator
12. The Mark Of Zorro
13. The Mortal Storm
14. Foreign Correspondent
15. The Sea Hawk
16. Dark Command
17. Santa Fe Trail

1941:

1. Citizen Kane
2. The Loyal 47 Ronin
3. The Lady Eve
4. The Maltese Falcon
5. Suspicion
6. Sullivan's Travels
7. Ball Of Fire
8. The Shanghai Gesture
9. 49th Parallel
10. How Green Was My Valley
11. Meet John Doe
12. Dumbo
13. High Sierra

1942:

1. Casablanca
2. The Palm Beach Story
3. I Married A Witch
4. Cat People
5. This Gun For Hire
6. The Magnificent Ambersons
7. Woman Of The Year
8. Bambi
9. Yankee Doodle Dandy
10. For Me And My Gal

1943:

1. The Life And Death Of Colonel Blimp
2. Day Of Wrath
3. I Walked With A Zombie
4. Shadow Of A Doubt
5. Sanshiro Sugata
6. Hangmen Also Die!
7. Cabin In The Sky
8. The 7th Victim
9. Meshes Of The Afternoon
10. The Leopard Man
11. Phantom Of The Opera

1944:

1. A Canterbury Tale
2. Ivan The Terrible Part 1
3. To Have And Have not
4. Laura
5. Double Indemnity
6. Lifeboat
7. Gaslight
8. Arsenic & Old Lace
9. Meet Me In St. Louis
10. Henry V
11. Murder, My Sweet
12. The Three Caballeros

1945:

1. Children Of Paradise
2. The Men Who Tread On The Tiger's Tail
3. I Know Where I'm Going!
4. Brief Encounter
5. Rome, Open City
6. They Were Expendable
7. Detour
8. The Clock
9. Spellbound
10. The Southerner
11. My Name Is Julia Ross
12. The Spiral Staircase
13. Mildred Pierce
14. Back To Bataan
15. Objective: Burma!
16. The Lost Weekend

1946:

1. The Big Sleep
2. It's A Wonderful Life
3. A Matter Of Life And Death
4. Notorious
5. Paisan
6. The Killers
7. Gilda
8. The Stranger
9. Beauty And The Beast
10. My Darling Clementine
11. Tomorrow Is Forever
12. Song Of The South
13. The Best Years Of Our Lives
14. The Postman Always Rings Twice
15. A Night In Casablanca

1947:

1. Black Narcissus
2. Out Of The Past
3. The Lady from Shanghai
4. Monsieur Verdoux
5. T-Men
6. Born To Kill
7. Dark Passage
8. Gentlemen's Agreement
9. Railroaded!

1948:

1. The Red Shoes
2. Red River
3. Rope
4. Fort Apache
5. Macbeth
6. Portrait Of Jennie
7. Force Of Evil
8. He Walked By Night
9. The Pirate
10. The Naked City
11. Bicycle Thieves
12. Hamlet
13. They Live By Night
14. The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre
15. 3 Godfathers
16. Key Largo
17. Berlin Express
18. A Foreign Affair
19. Easter Parade
20. The Three Musketeers

1949:

1. The Third Man
2. Late Spring
3. Stray Dog
4. The Set-Up
5. Jour de fête
6. Gun Crazy
7. She Wore A Yellow Ribbon
8. Kind Hearts And Coronets
9. Adam's Rib
10. Battleground
11. The Fountainhead
12. White Heat
13. On The Town
14. Sands Of Iwo Jima
15. The Adventures Of Ichabod And Mr. Toad
16. Knock On Any Door
17. Take Me Out To The Ballgame

1950:

1. Rashomon
2. All About Eve
3. Harvey
4. Winchester '73
5. Stromboli
6. In A Lonely Place
7. The Asphalt Jungle
8. Sunset Blvd.
9. Rio Grande
10. The Father Of The Bride
11. Cinderella
12. Born Yesterday
13. Where Danger Lives
14. DOA

1951:

1. The River
2. The Thing From Another World
3. Flying Leathernecks
4. Strangers On The Train
5. Diary Of A Country Priest
6. The Lavender Hill Mob
7. The Tales Of Hoffman
8. An American In Paris
9. The Day The Earth Stood Still
10. Alice In Wonderland
11. His Kind Of Woman
12. The Mating Season
13. The Tall Target
14. A Streetcar Named Desire
15. The African Queen
16. Miss Julie
17. Royal Wedding
18. A Place In The Sun
19. The Man From Planet X

1952:

1. Singin' In The Rain
2. Ikiru
3. The Quiet Man
4. Othello
5. Limelight
6. Bend Of The River
7. On Dangerous Ground
8. Europa '51
9. The Life Of Oharu
10. Rancho Notorious
11. The Big Sky
12. Monkey Business
13. The Narrow Margin
14. Angel Face
15. Clash By Night
16. The Bad And The Beautiful
17. High Noon

Thursday, July 19, 2007

Movie Roundup: The Blog From Another Planet Edition

Been crazy busy what with Metro Classics and Potter and Transformers and the old five year wedding anniversary a few days ago, but here's a quick rundown of what I've been watching over the last few weeks.

Bend Of The River - Much more to my liking as Anthony Mann Westerns go. James Stewart stars as an outlaw trying to make good as a wagon train guide along the Columbia River. Double crossed by badder guys than him, Stewart memorably goes a bit nuts on a mountainside. Lots of action and the kind of moral complexity you look for in a Mann-Stewart film.

The Southerner - The first American Jean Renoir film I've seen, it's the simple story of a sharecropping family trying to survive. It's got the director's trademark humanism, but is, perhaps interestingly, an all-white story with an all-white cast(e). Good, but still the worst Renoir I've seen.

Early Spring - Part of Criterion Eclipse boxset of Yasujiro Ozu's late films, possibly he best DVD purchase I've made all year. Like all Ozu films (as far as I know) it's a middle-class melodrama, this time centered around a salaryman's relationship with is with and the affair he has with a typist at the office. Some may claim Douglas Sirk as the king of the melodrama, but while I like Sirk, I'll take Ozu every time. The #2 film of 1956.

High Sierra - Mediocre Humphrey Bogart proto-noir about a bad guy on the run from the law. Costars Ida Lupino and directed by Raoul Walsh from a John Huston screenplay. John Ford said he didn't like Huston because he was a "faker". I do and don't know what that means.

Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer - Certainly better than the last one. I admire the lack of pretension and running time in a comic book movie, especially after dealing with the bloat that is Spiderman 3. But the ending doesn't make a whole lot of sense and the guy who play Dr. Doom is freakin' terrible.

Tokyo Twilight - As dark and as epic as Ozu gets, this brilliant film follows the melodramatic lives of a middle class Tokyo family. There's also abortions and suicides and whores and more. The #6 film of 1957.

The Seventh Victim - Another Val Lewton horror film, this one about a girl being hunted by Satanists. Not as good as the two Tourneur classics (Cat People and I Walked With A Zombie) but that's an unfair standard to hold any film to.

Father Of The Bride - The Vincent Minnelli version, with Spencer Tracy and Elizabeth Taylor. Of course it's better than the Steve Martin one. Tarcy's always great and Minnelli's densely-packed black and white photography is often amazing.

The Pit And The Pendulum - Another Roger Corman Poe adaptation starring Vincent Price. While it isn't quite as good as Masque Of The red Death, it's pretty great, with some wonderful expressionist sets and reasonably good performances from the non-Price actors. The #9 film of 1961.

Five Fingers Of Death - The original title, apparently of this Shaw brothers classic is King Boxer, but I like the US title better so I'm sticking with it. This was the first kung fu film to breakthrough in the US. Two rival schools fight a martial arts tournament, more or less. Except the bad guys do a lot of killing and eyeball plucking along the way. Great fun. The #5 film of 1972.

The One-Armed Swordsman - A bit less successful, though still very fine, is this earlier Shaw Brothers film about the eponymous maimed hero who overcomes his handicap to save his master and defeat the evildoers. A bit overlong, but the lead performance by Jimmy Wang Yu is pretty good. The #13 film of 1967.

Paris, je t'aime - Omnibus film made for the Cannes film festival is pretty entertaining, containing 18 short films by accomplished directors, each centered on a district of the City Of Lights. Alexander Payne's bittersweet story of an American tourist having an existential globalist epiphany is easily the best of them. But Vincenzo Natali's vampire fairy tale with Elijah Wood, Tom Tykwer's pomo relationship joke with Natalie Portman, Juliette Binoche's performance in Nobohiro Suwa story about overcoming grief with a cowboy Willem Dafoe and Walter Salles's Hou-esque story about an immigrant nanny. Most of the other shorts were entertaining, though Christopher Doyle's fantasy of dancing hair stylists was just plain confusing. With a late night Monday audience that was really into it, one of the more enjoyable theatre-going experiences I've had in awhile. The #15 film of 2006.

The Tarnished Angels - Based on a William Faulkner novel, this Douglas Sirk film follows the relationship between a journalist and a Depression Era stunt pilot and his family, notably the hot wife he treats like crap. The lead performances are very good (Rock Hudson, Robert Stack and Dorothy Malone, reunited from Written On The Wind) and Sirk's black and white 'Scope compositions are stunning. The #5 film of 1958.

Ratatouille - Quite possibly the best Pixar film thus far. Directed by Brad Bird, it's a simple story of a rat who wants to cook that manages to touch on art and community and family and identity and freedom and corporatism and criticism while masquerading as fun for the whole family slapstick. Most Pixar films have only one idea and that idea gets pounded into the ground until even the slowest kid in the audience understands that life in the fast lane loses some old highway magic, or whatever. Ratatouille overflows with ideas, and for the most part, they fly by: raising questions more than pounding answers.

The Good Shepherd - Very slick looking and surprisingly well-directed by Robert DeNiro, this story of the early days of the CIA fails on the level of plot and structure. A good performance from Matt Damon as the cipher at the center of the film, though his character is burdened with a cheesy Psych 101 backstory and an inexplicable relationship to Angelina Jolie (why does she like him? Why doesn't he like her??) The kind of film you spend the 20 minutes after watching nitpicking the ridiculous plot holes and contrivances. The #25 film of 2006.

Toy Story 2 - Certainly better than the first one. There's less sap to this sequel, and the sheer number of sci-fi film references is a lot of fun. But still at 92 minutes, it feels like it's at least 20 minutes too long. I think it's a failing of director John Lassiter, both the two Toy Storys and Cars suffer from Repetitive Theme Explication Syndrome. The #27 film of 1999.

Finding Nemo - Great looking Pixar film that's, I think, the best of the non-Brad Bird films. The story's a simple quest/coming of age story, but in managing to stick to the story action it avoids the preachiness that some other Pixar films suffer from. Most of the voice actors are pretty good, especially Willem Dafoe (are you ever not happy to discover Willem Dafoe's in a film you're watching?) Ellen DeGeneres is generally annoying though. The #14 film of 2003.

Transformers - It's no Armageddon, unfortunately. The first hour or so of Michael Bay's movie of a TV series designed to sell a toy is a lot of fun, with Shia LaBeouf playing the inevitable geeky teen who gets caught up in the action adventure (all while trying to impress a girl, naturally). There's some pleasant comedy with a car stereo and some giant robots in a lawn and John Turturro being really weird, but once the film turned into non-stop action mode, I lost interest. While Bay had slowed down his peripatetic camera for the first half, the second half is so clumsily edited as to be incomprehensible. The CGI is really impressive, but all the robots look the same. And none of them have any interesting personalities (absolutely no character for the giant shape-shifting robots).

Bells Are Ringing - Overlong Vincente Minnelli musical that features some really great music by Betty Comden and Adolph Green (Singin' In The Rain, The Band Wagon). Judy Holliday plays a answering service operator who gets involved in her clients lives and manages to fall in love under false pretenses with a writer played by Dean Martin. The actors are fine and Minnelli's terrific, but the song "The Party's Over" may be Comden and Green's best. The #11 film of 1960.

Love Affair - The original version of Leo McCarey's film that's been remade three times (as An Affair To Remember, by McCarey himself, as Sleepless In Seattle by Nora Ephron and as Love Affair with Warren Beatty and Annette Benning.) This one stars Irenne Dunne and Charles Boyer, they meet on a boat and even thought they're engaged to other people, fall in love. They agree to meet 6 months after returning to New York at the Empire State Building, but that doesn't quite work out. I still prefer McCarey's remake, with Cary Grant and Deborah Kerr, but very admirable in this film is its efficiency, with just as much plot and emotion as the other film, the film flies by at under 90 minutes. Yet another great film from that year 1939.

Designing Woman - Minor Minnelli? Lauren Bacall and Gregory Peck star as a mismatched pair of newlyweds in this mild comedy. He's a sportswriter, she's a fashion designer. Gasp! A woman with a job! Comedy ensues. There are also gangsters and a wholly unattractive ex-girlfriend that for some reason Bacall is threatened by. The #20 film of 1957.

Yankee Doodle Dandy - Well, the AFI's twice named it one of the best 100 "American" films of all-time, so it must be good, right? Well, Cagney's great, otherwise its a pretty standard jingoistic biopic.

Equinox Flower - Another film in the Ozu Eclipse box, this pone about the hypocrisies of a businessman father in his attitudes toward arranged marriage. He advises his friends daughters to marry for love, but becomes outraged when his own daughter wants to do exactly that. The most powerful moments, though, are the businessman and his friends reminiscing, drinking and singing over their youth in the war. The #7 film of 1958.

All That Heaven Allows - Douglas Sirk melodrama about a wealthy widow (Jane Wyman) who falls in love with the Thoreuvian tree farmer Rock Hudson, and has to choose between social pressure and the beatnik. Not helping matters are her fickle, flighty children. It's difficult to tell why Hudson likes Wyman so much, but the beauty of the film (lots of mirrors!) is undeniable. The #9 film of 1955.

This Gun For Hire - Speaking of beauty, Veronica Lake stars in this pseudonoir about a hired killer who gets double-crossed and has to kill the badder guys before the cops kill him. Lake plays the singing magician who gets hired by the FBI (apparently) to get evidence on what secrets the badder guys are selling to the Russians (chemical weapons, it turns out). Alan Ladd's performance as the killer, nicely named "Raven", made him a star. Directed by Frank Tuttle (Hell On Frisco Bay, The Glass Key) from a novel by Graham Greene.

Spielberg On Spielberg - Thoroughly mediocre Richard Shickel TCM documentary in which the director comments on a number of his films, but doesn't really bring up anything new. Notably, he calls Saving Private Ryan a tribute to his father and the Greatest Generation, and doesn't mention anything about war crimes or wanting to show how horrible war was, but wanted the young people in the audience to respect those who fought the war.

Police Story - On the one hand, this Jackie Chan-directed action film is a prime example of the protofascist cop genre that was so popular in the 70s and 80s (Dirty Harry, The French Connection, Police Academy, etc) as Chan plays a cop who goes completely off the rails, kidnaps his superior officer at gunpoint, proceeds to capture the bad guys and then beat the hell out of them after they've surrendered. On the other hand, Jackie Chan is totally insane and this film has some of the most amazing stunt work in any film I've ever seen. He's got at least one great sequence of physical comedy to leaven his irritatingly constant camera mugging, and the film costars Maggie Cheung (very young but still awesome in the generic HK action girlfriend role) and Brigitte Lin. The #4 film of 1985.

A Dog's Life - Charlie Chaplin adopts a dog, and the two seek love and food in this minor feature. Humorous at times, but nothing special for Chaplin.

Jamaica Inn - Curiously weak Alfred Hitchcock film with a bizarrely made-up Charles Laughton as the lord of a coastal British village who covertly runs a rings of pirates who lure ships onto the rocks, kill the sailors and steal their cargo. When Maureen O'Hara (in her screen debut) comes to town and falls in league with an undercover cop, things start to fall apart and Laughton begins to lose it. There are some fine, emotionally intense scenes, and Hitchcock is always an interesting director, but the film doesn't really standout. I blame Robert Newton as the bland hero/cop.

Police Story 2 - This sequel has a few good fight scenes, but none of the mania of Chan's previous film. Maggie Cheung is back, though. in another fine performance with a cliché part. Good, but not as mind-blowing as the first one. The #18 film of 1988.

Night Nurse - Barbara Stanwyck becomes the eponymous health care provider who gets in the way of Clark Gable's scheme to poison a little girl and run away with her liqueured-up mom. A fine film with a fair amount of pre-Code transgressiveness. Directed by William Wellman.

A Lost Lady - Another early Stanwyck, and though it's post-code, I liked it a lot better. She plays a depressed woman (her fiancé is killed by a jealous husband moments before their wedding) who meets Frank Morgan in Europe. He teaches her that life's worth living, and she marries him out of friendship. Then, inevitably, she meets a handsome aviator and has an affair. Stanwyck and Morgan were both terrific actors (even at this early stage of her career) and it's their performances that makes the melodrama work. Based on a Willa Cather novel.

Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix - I'm still waiting for a great Harry Potter film. The first one had it's flaws but I was totally charmed by it. The second was just treading water. The third, by Alfonso Cuarón was pretty good, directed with a great deal of style and bringing some darkness and maturity to the series. But the last two films, hampered by the need to adapt massive tomes into two and a half hour films choose to simplify to the point of cheese. Rather than make the films more efficient by cutting out all that's unnecessary, they make the films more simplistic by ripping all the emotional and narrative complexity out of the stories. The fifth book, on which this film is ostensibly based, is the darkest of any of the Harry Potter books, creating an effective facsimile of the angst and anger known to every 15 year old. There are hints of that anger in the first few minutes of this film, but after Potter begins teaching his classes, that emotional current entirely disappears. All that follows is plot. Someday there will be a good Potter film.

The Big Combo - Joseph H. Lewis's very black film noir stars Richard Conte as a crime boss being hunted by a persistent cop played by Cornel Wilde. A very taut 84 minutes long, filled with some of the darkest shadows and heartless characters I've seen in a noir. Lee Van Cleef and Earl Holliman play two of Conte's henchmen who are generally thought to be gay, which is why TCM played the movie for the first time ever last month. The #14 film of 1955.

Decision At Sundown - One of the seven Randolph Scott-Budd Boetticher westerns. In this one, Scott rides into town and breaks up a wedding so he can declare his intention to kill the groom. It seems the groom slept with Scott's wife while he was away fighting the Civil War, then killed herself when he came back. But what no one wants to tell Scott is, well, his wife was a slut and slept with any number of men while he was gone. Still, the local townspeople steer Scott into a showdown with the groom, since they don;t like the guy either and would rather get rid of him. Great complexity from a simple setup. The #9 film of 1957.

Comanche Station - The last of the Scott-Boetticher films. In what could almost be a sequel to The Searchers, Scott plays a man whose wife was kidnapped by Comanche and spends 10 years rescuing any white women he can from them (by trading, not shooting). When he rescues the very hot Nancy Gates and is on his way to return her to her husband, Claude Aikens comes along with two young gunmen and schemes to kill Scott and Gates and get the reward money for himself. Boetticher shoots the finale in what appears to be the same location as the end of Seven Men From Now, an alien amphitheater of round rocks surrounding a scrubland plain. Like with all his films, the action is as carefully designed as the character relationships, and out of simple straightforward setups grow profound resonances. The #10 film from 1960.

Rain - This 1932 film, in a great print on TCM has some impressive camera movement and expressiveness for the time from director Lewis Milestone (All Quiet On The Western Front, Ocean's 11). Joan Crawford plays a wiseguy prostitute on the precipitation-heavy island on Pongo Pongo who becomes the target of a soul saving by raving minister Walter Huston. The local sailors and libertarians to their best to rescue Crawford from morality, but she can take care of herself.

The Man From Planet X - This low budget Edgar G. Ulmer sci-fi film is apparently one of the first alien invasion films. There's not much good in the way of plot or acting, but Ulmer was a visual genius and the production design is spooky despite the cheapness.

And now playing on TCM, as we're rounded-up to the minute here at The End:

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Ichiro!


Dave Cameron recaps a tremendous day for Mariner news with only a little hyperbole:

Let’s recap:

Morning: Ted Miller quotes USSM in the P-I, then jumps on the Adam Jones bandwagon.

Afternoon: Ichiro re-signs with the Mariners.

Evening: Ichiro goes 3-3 with the first inside-the-park HR in all-star game history. Wins All-Star game MVP award.

Late Evening: Jason Churchill reports that the team will give Adam Jones a starting job and bench Jose Vidro on Thursday.

I’m not exaggerating when I say this is the best single day this franchise has had since October 8, 1995. On the heels of Felix Hernandez mixing his pitches after reading our open letter, the Mariners winning 3 of 4 in Oakland while going 14 and 4 in their last 18 games, and Mike Hargrove resigning as manager, it feels like we’ve been granted access to our own personal genie.

Sunday, July 08, 2007

Why Not 30?

Jim Emerson's got a thread calling for Top 30 "favortiest" films over at his Scanners blog. Since, of course, I am constitutionally incapable of resisting lists, I figured I'd add mine to the pile:

1. Seven Samurai
2. Chungking Express
3. Casablanca
4. The Rules Of The Game
5. Touch Of Evil
6. Manhattan
7. Singin' In The Rain
8. The Searchers
9. Pierrot Le Fou
10. The Big Lebowski
11. Millennium Mambo
12. Dr. Strangelove
13. Do The Right Thing
14. The Empire Strikes Back
15. Three Colors: Blue
16. Miller's Crossing
17. A Woman Is A Woman
18. Once Upon A Time In The West
19. Playtime
20. 8 1/2
21. Au hasard Balthazar
22. Sunrise
23. House Of Flying Daggers
24. The New World
25. The Third Man
26. North By Northwest
27. Ugetsu
28. Hard-Boiled
29. Duck Soup
30. Black Narcissus

Like all such movie lists, this is totally subjective, largely random and can change from moment to moment. But that doesn't mean it isn't fun, which is the whole point.

Thursday, June 21, 2007

A Word From Duff And Bill


A Shameless Plug from Vinyl Is Heavy.

The AFI updated its Top 100 American Films List last night, but I didn't know it was on and failed to watch it. The list's a bit better than the one from ten years ago, but not much. Apparently, "America" now not only includes England (Lawrence Of Arabia, Bridge On The River Kwai, several works by Stanley Kubrick), but New Zealand (Fellowship Of The Ring) as well. Yay America!

On the plus side, a number of Metro Classics made the list. Casablanca dropped from #2 to #3, and Taxi Driver went from #47 to #52 but The Searchers rode from #96 to #12, Duck Soup flew from #85 to #60, Sunrise burst onto the list at #82 and the right thing was done as Do The Right Thing joins the list at #96.

Speaking of Sunrise, did I mention it's playing at the Metro Cinemas next Wednesday, June 27? And that the rest of the Metro Classics will be playing every Wednesday for the rest of the summer? Bring you friends, meet Duff and Bill and score some free popcorn by mentioning The End Of Cinema.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Man Of The West, Revisited

A couple weeks ago I included a couple of lines dismissing Anthony Mann's Man Of The West in a speedy Movie Roundup:

"Mediocre Western starring the always(?) mediocre Gary Cooper. Anthony Mann made far better films, I was just never into it. Maybe I should give it another shot? The #13 film of 1958."

Which prompted a detailed response from faithful reader Andrew, in which he asserts that the film is, in his opinion, the best Western ever, and possibly the best American film of the last 50 years. He urged me to revisit the film and come up with a more detailed response to it. Well, it was on TCM last week, and I watched it again, being careful to pay closer attention to it. What follows is Andrew's comments and my responses to them.

Cooper's performance is brilliant, a perfect portrait of a dying man who can barely muster the energy for one last burst of violence, though I can see why some people might not be so impressed by it or Cooper in general. I know many are turned off by his overemphatic "folksy" delivery, but watch any of his good movies with the sound off for a few minutes and you'll see a great performer whose moves, looks, and gestures are perfectly choreographed. Then watch him with sound again, and you'll probably be more impressed.


Acting is a difficult thing for someone like me, who knows very little about that art. But I do know what I like, and Gary Cooper isn't it. I will admit that Cooper's a wonderful physical actor, his comic sequences in the beginning of the film, showing his characters discomfort in both a town and a train are well done. But his voice bugs the hell out of me and he always seems to have the same expression on his face (a kind of befuddled determination) which works in some films (The Fountainhead) but not really here.

Part of the problem is that he's playing a Mann character that James Stewart set the type for: the former outlaw trying to go straight and sucked back into a world of violence. This is set up well in the beginning (the aforementioned fish out of water jokes) but falls apart towards the end, when Cooper seems bored where Stewart brought a maniacal intensity to the same role in films like Bend Of The River or The Naked Spur. This is a game Cooper can't help but lose: Stewart's quite possibly my favorite actor.

Mann's direction, though, is impeccable; it reaches the level of the best work of Rossellini, Melville, Ford, and Bresson, where every composition and camera movement is perfect and, more important, _necessary_ to the whole. Watch the way Mann tracks back behind a wagon wheel as a humiliated outlaw crawls for a gun, or the astonishing way in which he shoots the climax in the ghost town. The latter sequence is the definition of great action direction; the spatial relationships are so clear you could draw a map of the entire event after one viewing (see the beautiful track capturing Jones and the two gunmen in one shot), and the way Mann splits up horizontal and vertical areas of the Scope screen to define the action reveals a more sophisticated formalist than Peckinpah or Leone.


This I must agree with absolutely. The final shootout sequence in the ghost town is brilliantly done, both in the mise-en-scene (an empty wasteland of a town, devoid of both human and vegetal life (except for the poor Mexican couple who get caught in the crossfire) and in the camera movement. The crane shot up and away from Cooper preceding the final battle is as elegant as anything in the genre. Mann was a great director, and like any great director there's always something interesting in even their worst films (which this film isn't for sure).

I agree he's superior to Peckinpaugh, but Leone's aesthetic is so radically different (while being similar, perhaps, thematically) that I wouldn't compare them in this way.

But unlike those two directors, who he resembles and influences in his violence and awareness of genre, Mann brings a genuine, unironic sense of tragedy to the action; both the urgency and the inevitability of the theme (all the usual suspects: desert/garden, outlaw violence/civilized community contrasts, inescapable past) are felt more strongly than in similar (and similarly great) films from My Darling Clementine and The Searchers to The Wild Bunch and Ride the High Country.


Here I disagree, Yes, the film is thematically similar to many great Westerns, with the usual oppositions in place and worked out through the action. But this film feels far more schematic and theatrical than the best Westerns (The Searchers, Once Upon A Time In The West, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence, Winchester 73, Unforgiven). The characters in Man Of The West never feel real and organically human, but instead as echoes of Mann films past. Part of the problem is the acting (aside from Cooper, it's a collection of unremarkable B-listers and scenery-chewers) and part of it is the construction of the narrative itself. I'm still trying to figure out when the film took place (less than ten years after the railroad reached eastern Texas, I guess, but wasn't that long before The End Of The West that the film thematically deals with?) or why Cooper, after being left behind by the train went straight to his old gang's hideout, or why the fugitive gambler is such a coward (he was outlaw enough to be known by the Law) or why the only people left behind by the train are the two who'd previously interacted with Cooper, or why the gang thought they'd rob a bank in a ghost town (it's established that the crazy old leader is totally out of touch, but why are his underlings as well?). There are more holes and questions that keep popping up and I think that no matter how great the directing, a narrative so full of holes just can't be a truly great genre film. I spend too much time asking questions about the story to care about the characters or the ideas the film is trying to convey.

I only saw it for the first time a year ago, when it immediately vaulted into my all-time top ten, and subsequent viewings confirm its greatness. I can only urge you to take a longer look, or else figure out more concretely what about the film doesn't work for you.


I thank Andrew for his post, because Mann certainly deserved a closer look than I initially gave the film, but in the end my feeling for it hasn't changed much. The film it most reminded me of was Howard Hawks's Rio Lobo: a fine film, but one he had done better a few times before. I'd rank any of the Mann-Stewart Westerns above this, as well as several films by Ford, Hawks, Leone, Eastwood and the Westerns I've seen from Fuller, Boetticher and possibly even Peckinpaugh. I'm comfortable with it as my #13 film of 1958, though I may bump it above Gigi, but I should watch that film (which I haven't seen since college) again before making a final decision.