Mother - In a plot eerily similar, and yet totally different, from Lee Chang-dong's 2010 film Poetry, Kim Hye-ja sees her developmentally disabled son accused of murdering a young girl. Initially she pleads for help from the police, former customers (she's an unlicensed acupuncturist), and an arrogant attorney, even the victim's family, each time adopting a submissive tone of voice and humble mannerisms, straightening and saddening every time she gets shot down. Eventually, with some advice and help from one of her son's friends, she takes it upon herself to investigate the crime and find the real killer. Her actions once she does are what limit this to being merely a clever genre exercise with a cynical, rather depressing view of the world. It's as funny, at least in the beginning, as director Bong Joon-ho's last film, the very fine monster movie The Host, but it leaves you cold. Poetry, on the other hand, has a much more expansive and tragic view of life and its characters, a real affection for them that Bong's more narrow film doesn't allow. Or at least, in the film's final scenes, our sympathy with the Mother either feels forced at best and satirical at worst. The #33 film of 2009.
Genius Within: The Inner Life of Glenn Gould - I can't imagine a less exciting documentary about such a fascinating musician. Like most of the worst examples of its genre, it puts the focus on the artist's personal life (which is exceptionally dull, even for a Canadian) instead of their work, which is the reason we want to see a documentary about him anyway (for a much better example of how to make a classical music doc, see In Search of Beethoven, from a couple of years ago). Aside from a few sparse scenes with one of Gould's conservatory classmates, wherein she demonstrates the radically different approaches Gould took to various pieces of music, there's almost no discussion of the actual music he created. Worse than that, we get no real context to place Gould within his era, either of post-war classical music, or the wider culture of the 50s and 60s. The best we get on that end are overblown claims of Gould's importance in recording music in a studio in the 1970s, as if he invented the idea of splicing different takes together. The best parts of the movie are archival interviews with Gould, where he is articulate, funny, and a bit kooky, though he never seems as weird as the various talking heads seem to think he was. Maybe that's a genre thing, or considering that the only popular musician mentioned in the film is Petula Clark, maybe the filmmakers really just don't have any idea of what was going on in pop culture in Gould's time. The #59 film of 2009.
No comments:
Post a Comment